An American tech company provides custom-made software to a foreign government. That government uses the technology to identify, kidnap, torture, and murder members of a religious minority. At the foreign government’s request, the tech company makes updates to the software that make it even more efficient at identifying members of the religious minority through online surveillance. Survivors of the religious persecution sue the tech company in U.S. courts for the role it played in their torture and the murders of their family members. And they lose. These are the facts, as alleged by the plaintiff-appellants, in Cisco Systems, Inc. v. Doe, which the U.S. Supreme Court decided in July 2026.
As the latest Alien Tort Statute (ATS) ruling, the Supreme Court foreclosed most opportunities for victims of human rights abuses to bring civil lawsuits against their perpetrators using the ATS. Cisco was filed by practitioners of the Falun Gong religion in China. For many years, the Chinese government has persecuted Falun Gong practitioners by kidnappings, torture, “re-education,” and even death. The Chinese government enlisted the assistance of foreign technology companies to develop novel tools for surveilling and tracking those practitioners. In this case, plaintiffs alleged that Cisco Systems, Inc., based in San Jose, California, provided the Chinese government with specially customized technology for the surveillance and identification of Falun Gong members.
This blog post first focuses on the facts of the case and the historical usage of the ATS. It next discusses the court’s ruling on the ATS and Torture Victim Protection Act (TVPA) claims, and what they mean for the future of the ATS. It concludes with some thoughts on the future of the ATS and human rights litigation in U.S. courts.
The Cisco Decision: The Facts
For decades, China’s government has conducted a campaign of persecution against practitioners of a religion called Falun Gong. Falun Gong was founded in China during the 1990s, and it promotes pacificism, compassion, and the concept of karma—that the good deeds of this life follow into the next. Falun Gong was originally part of a state-sanctioned group, but following the budding religion’s departure from that group, the Chinese government renounced the group and targeted members in crackdowns beginning in 1999. It is estimated that since the crackdown began, hundreds of thousands of Falun Gong practitioners have been abducted, imprisoned, and tortured.
According to the plaintiffs, Cisco created a personalized software dubbed the ‘Golden Shield’ that allowed the Chinese government to identify and locate Falun Gong practitioners by analyzing patterns of internet usage. This specialized software reportedly made it much easier for the Chinese government to conduct its campaign of persecution.
Despite global outrage at China’s treatment of Falun Gong practitioners, there have been few opportunities for the victims to seek redress for their treatment. In Cisco v. Doe, several victims of Chinese torture and the families of those murdered by the regime for their religious beliefs filed suit against Cisco Systems for the role the company played in their persecution. The victims and families contended that by providing customized software that significantly assisted the Chinese government in tracking, identifying, kidnapping, torturing, converting, and in some cases, murdering Falun Gong practitioners, Cisco aided and abetted these violations of international law.
A Primer on the ATS
Since the 1980s, victims of human rights abuses have been using the ATS to hold the perpetrators of human rights abuses accountable. Initially passed as part of the Judiciary Act of 1789, the ATS (today codified at 28 U.S.C. § 1350) is a one-sentence statute that gives U.S. district courts “original jurisdiction of any civil action by an alien for a tort only, committed in violation of the law of nations or a treaty of the United States.” The “law of nations” is analogous to the modern day concept of customary international law (CIL). CIL encompasses an amorphous body of law that develops over time and represents what nations perceive as universally (or near universally) obligatory laws or customs, which are demonstrated through their own state practices.
Some examples of CIL include the prohibition against genocide, torture, slavery, and crimes against humanity. While some international treaties codify nations’ agreement not to commit these acts, the prohibition against states committing these acts is also part of CIL, meaning even states not party to those treaties must abide by the CIL rules.
In the last few decades, however, the U.S. Supreme Court has slowly dismantled the ATS. In a line of cases beginning around 2004, the Supreme Court narrowed the application of the ATS to individual people, U.S. corporations, and to conduct that occurs within the United States, or conduct that occurs outside of the country but “touches and concerns” the United States. Today, this means that foreign corporations cannot be sued under the ATS, and that any conduct occurring outside the United States must have a significant connection to the United States to allow an ATS case to proceed. Further, to meet the ATS requirement of conduct constituting a violation of the law of nations, the conduct must violate a norm that is “specific, universal, and obligatory.” That is a very high threshold to meet.
The TVPA
Most of the plaintiffs in Cisco are foreign nationals, and therefore brought this suit against Cisco under the ATS. However, one victim is a U.S. citizen. Because only foreign nationals can bring claims under the ATS, he instead brought a claim under the TVPA, alleging that two individual Cisco executives aided and abetted his torture.
The TVPA provides a private right of action against anyone who, “under actual or apparent authority, or under color of law of any foreign nation– subjects any individual to torture . . . [or] to extrajudicial killing.”
The TVPA explicitly allows victims of torture to sue their attackers. Because the victims alleged they were tortured by the Chinese government (i.e., “under color of foreign law”), they filed a claim against Cisco under the TVPA.
Due to foreign sovereign immunity, the plaintiffs could not sue the Chinese government. Instead, they alleged that Cisco substantially assisted the Chinese government in its torture through their custom-made technology. Therefore, the plaintiffs alleged, Cisco aided and abetted the torture of Falun Gong practitioners.
The Cisco Decisions: The Alien Tort Statute
The Supreme Court ruled in this case that the plaintiffs could not sue Cisco under either the ATS or the TVPA. In a decision written by Justice Amy Coney Barrett and joined by five other justices, the Court held that federal courts could not create new causes of action for violations of international norms under the ATS, meaning here plaintiffs could not argue that aiding and abetting is a norm actionable under the ATS. In other words, the Court does not believe that the ATS allows Falun Gong practitioners to sue Cisco for aiding and abetting the alleged violations of international law. To reach this conclusion, the Court relied on its precedent in the 2004 case Sosa v. Alvarez-Machain.
In Sosa, the Court held that the ATS is a jurisdictional statute, conferring no cause of action in itself. (A cause of action is a sort of ticket into court - a reason why someone should be allowed to sue). But the First Congress, said Justice Souter there, did not intend to “leave [the ATS] lying fallow indefinitely.” Sosa, then, permits courts to exercise jurisdiction “for a relatively modest set of actions alleging violations of the law of nations,” to be determined by a two step test. The first step is to determine whether the norm that was allegedly violated has a “definite content and acceptance among civilized nations.” This means a norm must be sufficiently “specific, universal, and obligatory.” Second, the plaintiff must show that creating a cause of action will not inappropriately affect foreign policy, which is primarily the realm of the political branches. The Cisco plaintiffs argued that their claims passed the Sosa test.
Nonetheless, using this two-step framework, the Court in Cisco reasoned that because ATS cases inherently “implicate foreign policy” by contemplating norms of international character, it is hard to imagine an ATS case that would not create “detrimental foreign policy consequences.” Additionally, the Court held that Congress is better equipped than courts to create causes of action under the ATS (as Congress did with the TVPA), and that deferring to congressional action or inaction here would better protect the separation of powers.
Cisco, at bottom, held that “[c]ourts cannot create new rights of action to remedy violations of international law.” Because there are no new rights of action, there also cannot be aiding and abetting liability for those violations, and plaintiffs could not maintain their ATS claims against Cisco.
The Cisco Decision: The Torture Statute
The Court also addressed the TVPA claims of aiding and abetting torture. In Central Bank of Denver, M.A. v. First Interstate Bank of Denver, N.A. the Court held there was no aiding and abetting liability under the Securities Exchange Act because the Act did not expressly provide for it. Citing this precedent, the Court ruled that because the TVPA does not expressly mention a cause of action for aiding and abetting liability, there is none.
The TVPA creates a cause of action only against those who “subject” another person to torture. Based on this language, the Court reasoned that the cause of action would only apply to those who directly inflicted the torture (“subjected” them to the torture), rather than to those who aided and abetted it. Because the Court reasoned that one who indirectly contributes to torture cannot “subject” someone to torture, the Court held that there is no aiding-and-abetting liability under the TVPA.
Disappointingly for the victims and survivors of China’s persecution against the Falun Gong, this ruling significantly decreases these plaintiffs’ ability to receive any form of redress in this case. The Court remanded to the 9th Circuit, where plaintiffs argue that their state law claims for battery, assault, and false imprisonment survived Cisco. Beyond these plaintiffs, the decision is a disappointing result that makes it increasingly difficult for victims of egregious corporate abuses to receive any sort of remedy under the ATS.
Moving Forward
Just because the court held there are no new rights of action does not mean there are no rights of action under the ATS. The Cisco decision includes a discussion of the state of the law of nations at the time the ATS was passed, in 1789. At this time, William Blackstone, a legal scholar, published a treatise that listed three primary offenses against the law of nations: violations of safe conducts, infringements of the rights of ambassadors, and piracy. Although Cisco closes the door on new causes of action, it is understood that these three ‘original’ law-of-nations violations (the Blackstone Three) remain valid causes of action under the ATS.
For human rights advocates, this narrowing of the ATS to just three causes of action is a major blow, but a narrow category of cases may still be viable.
In the past, the Second Circuit wrote that “for purposes of civil liability, the torturer has become—like the pirate and slave trader before him—hostis humani generis, an enemy of all mankind.” Filartiga v. Pena-Irala. Plaintiffs could argue that corporations acting as modern-day pirates are therefore still liable under the ATS. For example, fishing vessels that engage in forced labor could be analogized to pirates; they are privately-owned ships committing violence and abuses against individuals on the high seas.
But if the post-Cisco decision in Al Shimari v. CACI, a landmark ATS jury verdict, is any indication, such arguments are an uphill battle, and suggests that courts may only find traditional piracy on the high seas, not an analogy to piracy, to constitute a valid claim. The Fourth Circuit in August 2026 vacated its prior decision in Al Shimari, upholding a massive jury verdict, and remanded with instructions to dismiss the case. Judge Quattlebaum, concurring, wrote that although Cisco preserved the Blackstone Three, “[t]he Supreme Court left no room for such creative pleading” as arguing that torturers are pirates.
Another possible lifeline for the TVPA is command responsibility: the idea that commanding officers are vicariously liable for their subordinates’ actions. The majority does not reject, or even discuss, command responsibility as a theory of TVPA liability. Justice Sotomayor, however, in dissent criticizes the majority’s “narrow interpretation of the word ‘subjects’” in the TVPA, arguing that the Court’s precedent recognizing command responsibility means that TVPA should be interpreted more broadly.
The United States’ amicus brief agreed, writing that the TVPA captures command responsibility as a theory of liability, and that such commanders are “not merely an aider and abettor.” So while claims alleging aiding and abetting torture are no longer viable under the statute, command responsibility appears to remain intact, providing for liability for those who order torture, not just the torturers themselves.
In her dissent, Justice Sotomayor lambasts the majority for ignoring stare decisis, stating that this decision “marks yet another low point in this Court’s esteem for its precedents.” While this narrowing of the Alien Tort Statute and the TVPA is a blow to human rights litigation in the United States, human rights litigators have always represented their clients zealously and creatively, and will no doubt continue to do so.
Grace Kowalevsky was a CAL intern and is a 3L at UCLA Law School. Tony Maquiling is a legal fellow at CAL and provided additional edits.


